Purdue University’s 2023 report on agricultural confined space-related injuries and fatalities reveals both alarming trends and areas of improvement within the industry. While there has been a notable decrease in the number of incidents compared to previous years, the statistics underscore the ongoing risks associated with confined spaces in agriculture.
Key Findings
- Overall Cases: A total of 55 cases were documented in 2022, which includes 29 fatal and 26 non-fatal incidents. This represents a significant 33.7% decrease from the 83 cases recorded in 2021.
- Grain Entrapments: The report documented 27 grain-related entrapments in 2022, showing a 35.7% decrease from the previous year. The remaining cases involved livestock waste handling, entanglements, and incidents related to grain dust explosions or fires.
- Multiple Victims: Three incidents involved multiple victims, highlighting the potential for widespread danger in confined spaces.
- Gender Representation: The report noted two female cases, including a dairy farm manure pit explosion and a fall from a grain elevator.
- Geographic Distribution: Illinois reported the highest number of confined space-related cases (12), followed by Iowa (5). Historical data indicates that states like Iowa, Indiana, and Minnesota continue to account for a large percentage of grain entrapment cases.
- Grain Dust Explosions: There were nine documented grain dust explosions at commercial facilities, resulting in 12 non-fatal injuries. Fortunately, no fatalities were reported in these incidents.
- Aging Workforce: The average age of victims continues to rise, reflecting the increasing age of farmers in the U.S. In 2022, victims over 60 years old made up 28.6% of the cases where age was known.
Trends and Insights
Since the 1970s, Purdue University’s Agricultural and Biological Engineering Department has diligently documented incidents involving grain storage and handling facilities. This effort expanded in 2013 to include a broader range of agricultural confined space incidents, resulting in a comprehensive database (PACSID) containing 2,378 cases as of the end of 2022.
Despite the positive trend of fewer incidents, the report emphasizes the persistent need for effective safety training and proactive measures to protect workers. The methodology for collecting this data remains consistent, and while the numbers show improvement, the report acknowledges that many incidents, particularly non-fatal cases, may go unreported.
The Cost of Agricultural Confined Space-Related Incidents is Increasing
The economic implications of agricultural confined space incidents have changed significantly over time. In the past, the costs associated with fatalities or injuries were often manageable, covered by family, insurance policies, or local community support. However, with stricter OSHA regulations and increased scrutiny on workplace safety, non-exempt employers now face substantial financial risks. Jurisdictions have highlighted that neglecting employee safety can lead to hefty legal settlements, often reaching $10-17 million in cases involving fatalities or serious injuries, dwarfing OSHA fines that typically range from $50,000 to $100,000.
Valuable Resources for Safety Training
To aid in addressing these challenges, the website http://www.agconfinedspaces.org/ has been developed with support from a U.S. Department of Labor Susan Harwood Grant. This platform provides resources for safety training in agricultural confined spaces, focusing on grain storage and handling hazards. It includes:
- Training materials and frequently asked questions.
- Historical summaries of injuries and fatalities.
- Educational resources aimed at young and beginning workers in the grain industry.
One highlighted program, “Against the Grain,” offers a comprehensive curriculum designed for youth and new employees at grain handling facilities. Since its launch, it has reached over 5,100 young individuals, demonstrating significant knowledge gains.
Additionally, training resources for emergency responders have been developed, with over 5,425 responders participating in these training sessions.
Conclusion
The findings from the 2023 report underscore the importance of focusing not only on reducing the number of incidents but also on strategically enhancing training for first responders. As the agricultural industry continues to evolve, so must our approaches to safety and emergency preparedness.
For a detailed look at the 2022 findings, methodology, and historical trends, please refer to the full report here.